0.05/0.09 % Problem : SLH312^1 : TPTP v7.5.0. Released v7.5.0. 0.05/0.10 % Command : run_E %s %d THM 0.10/0.30 % Computer : n025.cluster.edu 0.10/0.30 % Model : x86_64 x86_64 0.10/0.30 % CPU : Intel(R) Xeon(R) CPU E5-2620 v4 @ 2.10GHz 0.10/0.30 % Memory : 8042.1875MB 0.10/0.30 % OS : Linux 3.10.0-693.el7.x86_64 0.10/0.30 % CPULimit : 30 0.10/0.30 % WCLimit : 30 0.10/0.30 % DateTime : Tue Aug 9 02:53:41 EDT 2022 0.10/0.30 % CPUTime : 0.15/0.39 The problem SPC is TH0_THM_EQU_NAR 0.15/0.39 Running higher-order on 1 cores theorem proving 0.15/0.39 Running: /export/starexec/sandbox2/solver/bin/eprover-ho --delete-bad-limit=2000000000 --definitional-cnf=24 -s --print-statistics -R --print-version --proof-object --auto-schedule=1 --cpu-limit=30 /export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p 0.15/0.40 # Version: 3.0pre003-ho 0.36/0.57 # Preprocessing class: HSLMSMSSSSMNHFA. 0.36/0.57 # Scheduled 1 strats onto 1 cores with 30 seconds (30 total) 0.36/0.57 # Starting lpo5_fix with 30s (1) cores 0.36/0.57 # lpo5_fix with pid 15682 completed with status 0 0.36/0.57 # Result found by lpo5_fix 0.36/0.57 # Preprocessing class: HSLMSMSSSSMNHFA. 0.36/0.57 # Scheduled 1 strats onto 1 cores with 30 seconds (30 total) 0.36/0.57 # Starting lpo5_fix with 30s (1) cores 0.36/0.57 # No SInE strategy applied 0.36/0.57 # Search class: HGUSM-FSLM32-MHFFFSBN 0.36/0.57 # Scheduled 4 strats onto 1 cores with 30 seconds (30 total) 0.36/0.57 # Starting lpo5_fix with 19s (1) cores 0.36/0.57 # lpo5_fix with pid 15683 completed with status 0 0.36/0.57 # Result found by lpo5_fix 0.36/0.57 # Preprocessing class: HSLMSMSSSSMNHFA. 0.36/0.57 # Scheduled 1 strats onto 1 cores with 30 seconds (30 total) 0.36/0.57 # Starting lpo5_fix with 30s (1) cores 0.36/0.57 # No SInE strategy applied 0.36/0.57 # Search class: HGUSM-FSLM32-MHFFFSBN 0.36/0.57 # Scheduled 4 strats onto 1 cores with 30 seconds (30 total) 0.36/0.57 # Starting lpo5_fix with 19s (1) cores 0.36/0.57 # Preprocessing time : 0.009 s 0.36/0.57 0.36/0.57 # Proof found! 0.36/0.57 # SZS status Theorem 0.36/0.57 # SZS output start CNFRefutation 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_22, type, if_Ref498805583od_b_a: $o > refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_23, type, if_Ref1369692790t_unit: $o > refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_24, type, if_Ref1724547303nres_a: $o > refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_25, type, if_Ref1732808808nres_b: $o > refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_26, type, if_b: $o > b > b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_27, type, ord_le1135777269od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_28, type, ord_le1051254044t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_29, type, ord_le519537037nres_a: refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_30, type, ord_le527798542nres_b: refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_31, type, ord_le2044239718od_b_a: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_32, type, ord_le1023748749t_unit: set_Product_unit > set_Product_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_33, type, ord_less_eq_set_a: set_a > set_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_34, type, ord_less_eq_set_b: set_b > set_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_35, type, top_to177290092t_unit: refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_36, type, produc212743870t_unit: product_prod_b_a > product_unit > produc1069747022t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_37, type, produc781771951_b_a_a: product_prod_b_a > a > produc1884350911_b_a_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_38, type, produc1076565719t_unit: product_unit > product_unit > produc971140967t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_39, type, produc1799512520unit_a: product_unit > a > produc884009688unit_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_40, type, produc1799512521unit_b: product_unit > b > produc892271193unit_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_41, type, produc2127022719od_b_a: a > product_prod_b_a > produc2141558671od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_42, type, produc1776699686t_unit: a > product_unit > produc1767851702t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_43, type, product_Pair_a_a: a > a > product_prod_a_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_44, type, product_Pair_a_b: a > b > product_prod_a_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_45, type, produc1248785854od_b_a: b > product_prod_b_a > produc1263321806od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_46, type, produc1895952485t_unit: b > product_unit > produc1887104501t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_47, type, product_Pair_b_a: b > a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_48, type, product_Pair_b_b: b > b > product_prod_b_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_49, type, product_Unity: product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_50, type, refine914559736t_unit: (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > $o > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_51, type, refine2039610767ASSERT: $o > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_52, type, refine1328363980od_b_a: product_prod_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_53, type, refine1420258419t_unit: product_unit > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_54, type, refine2063221604TURN_a: a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_55, type, refine2063221605TURN_b: b > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_56, type, refine933121206od_b_a: set_Pr1907304967od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_57, type, refine139011933t_unit: set_Pr975006126t_unit > refine891721109od_b_a > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_58, type, refine1164562510_b_a_a: set_Pr1591822495_b_a_a > refine891721109od_b_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_59, type, refine1164562511_b_a_b: set_Pr583903136_b_a_b > refine891721109od_b_a > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_60, type, refine838861686t_unit: set_Pr451126599t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_61, type, refine362329630od_b_a: set_Pr454823535od_b_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_62, type, refine1136779702un_a_a: set_Product_prod_a_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_63, type, refine1964549109un_b_a: set_Product_prod_b_a > refine432681134nres_b > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_64, type, refine493344070od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > (product_prod_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a) > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_65, type, refine1040452959od_b_a: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine891721109od_b_a) > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_66, type, refine681446406t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_67, type, refine119808503unit_a: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_68, type, refine119808504unit_b: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_69, type, refine436832838nd_a_a: refine424419629nres_a > (a > refine424419629nres_a) > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_70, type, refine1264602246nd_b_b: refine432681134nres_b > (b > refine432681134nres_b) > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_71, type, refine2137707516t_unit: set_Pr975006126t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_72, type, refine1290631149_b_a_a: set_Pr1591822495_b_a_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_73, type, refine1290631150_b_a_b: set_Pr583903136_b_a_b > refine432681134nres_b > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_74, type, refine944483349t_unit: set_Pr451126599t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_75, type, refine2043866374unit_a: set_Pr1720557880unit_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_76, type, refine2043866375unit_b: set_Pr712638521unit_b > refine432681134nres_b > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_77, type, refine488398269od_b_a: set_Pr454823535od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_78, type, refine2021053540t_unit: set_Pr1628433942t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_79, type, refine1441824853un_a_a: set_Product_prod_a_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_80, type, refine1441824854un_a_b: set_Product_prod_a_b > refine432681134nres_b > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_81, type, refine1757645052od_b_a: set_Pr1323534894od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_82, type, refine2140306339t_unit: set_Pr1707992533t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_83, type, refine122110612un_b_a: set_Product_prod_b_a > refine424419629nres_a > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_84, type, refine122110613un_b_b: set_Product_prod_b_b > refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_85, type, refine355838867od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_86, type, refine558004794t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_87, type, refine1001002027nres_a: refine424419629nres_a > a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_88, type, refine1001002028nres_b: refine432681134nres_b > b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_89, type, refine1149660768sn_b_a: set_Product_prod_b_a > (a > $o) > b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_90, type, refine1206730187od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_91, type, refine983493746t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_92, type, refine1312857699nres_a: refine424419629nres_a > a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_93, type, refine1312857700nres_b: refine432681134nres_b > b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_94, type, refine733113405od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_95, type, refine579265252t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_96, type, refine412683989fail_a: refine424419629nres_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_97, type, refine412683990fail_b: refine432681134nres_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_98, type, refine1450221040od_b_a: set_Product_prod_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_99, type, refine1777164439t_unit: set_Product_unit > refine787176636t_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_100, type, refine1198353288_RES_a: set_a > refine424419629nres_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_101, type, refine1198353289_RES_b: set_b > refine432681134nres_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_102, type, refine874176461od_b_a: refine891721109od_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_103, type, refine1208325748t_unit: refine787176636t_unit > set_Product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_104, type, refine1822134885_RES_a: refine424419629nres_a > set_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_105, type, refine1822134886_RES_b: refine432681134nres_b > set_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_106, type, collec1473625041od_b_a: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > set_Product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_107, type, collect_Product_unit: (product_unit > $o) > set_Product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_108, type, collect_a: (a > $o) > set_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_109, type, collect_b: (b > $o) > set_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_110, type, member1751446391t_unit: produc1069747022t_unit > set_Pr975006126t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_111, type, member123322088_b_a_a: produc1884350911_b_a_a > set_Pr1591822495_b_a_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_112, type, member1423014800t_unit: produc971140967t_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_113, type, member1211819009unit_a: produc884009688unit_a > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_114, type, member1220080514unit_b: produc892271193unit_b > set_Pr712638521unit_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_115, type, member380529848od_b_a: produc2141558671od_b_a > set_Pr454823535od_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_116, type, member2095661023t_unit: produc1767851702t_unit > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_117, type, member449909584od_a_a: product_prod_a_a > set_Product_prod_a_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_118, type, member458171089od_a_b: product_prod_a_b > set_Product_prod_a_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_119, type, member1649776631od_b_a: produc1263321806od_b_a > set_Pr1323534894od_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_120, type, member67430174t_unit: produc1887104501t_unit > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_121, type, member1277678991od_b_a: product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_122, type, member1285940496od_b_b: product_prod_b_b > set_Product_prod_b_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_123, type, member_Product_unit: product_unit > set_Product_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_124, type, member_a: a > set_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_125, type, member_b: b > set_b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_126, type, r: set_Product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_127, type, x: set_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_128, type, x2: b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_129, type, esk1_0: a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_130, type, esk2_2: set_Product_unit > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_131, type, esk3_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_132, type, esk4_2: set_b > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_133, type, esk5_2: set_a > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_134, type, esk6_2: (a > $o) > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_135, type, esk7_2: (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_136, type, esk8_2: (b > $o) > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_137, type, esk9_2: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_138, type, esk10_2: set_a > refine424419629nres_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_139, type, esk11_2: set_Product_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_140, type, esk12_2: set_b > refine432681134nres_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_141, type, esk13_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_142, type, esk14_3: refine424419629nres_a > (a > $o) > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_143, type, esk15_3: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_144, type, esk16_3: refine432681134nres_b > (b > $o) > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_145, type, esk17_3: refine891721109od_b_a > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_146, type, esk18_3: product_unit > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_147, type, esk19_3: a > set_Product_prod_a_a > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_148, type, esk20_3: b > set_Product_prod_b_a > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_149, type, esk21_3: b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_150, type, esk22_3: product_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_151, type, esk23_3: a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_152, type, esk24_3: b > set_Product_prod_b_b > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_153, type, esk25_3: product_unit > set_Pr712638521unit_b > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_154, type, esk26_3: a > set_Product_prod_a_b > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_155, type, esk27_3: product_prod_b_a > set_Pr1591822495_b_a_a > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_156, type, esk28_3: product_unit > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_157, type, esk29_3: a > set_Product_prod_a_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_158, type, esk30_3: b > set_Product_prod_b_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_159, type, esk31_3: b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_160, type, esk32_3: product_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_161, type, esk33_3: a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_162, type, esk34_3: b > set_Product_prod_b_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_163, type, esk35_3: product_unit > set_Pr712638521unit_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_164, type, esk36_3: a > set_Product_prod_a_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_165, type, esk37_3: product_prod_b_a > set_Pr1591822495_b_a_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_166, type, esk38_3: set_a > set_a > set_Product_prod_a_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_167, type, esk39_3: set_a > set_Product_unit > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_168, type, esk40_3: set_a > set_b > set_Product_prod_a_b > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_169, type, esk41_3: set_Product_unit > set_a > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_170, type, esk42_3: set_Product_unit > set_Product_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_171, type, esk43_3: set_Product_unit > set_b > set_Pr712638521unit_b > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_172, type, esk44_3: set_b > set_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_173, type, esk45_3: set_b > set_Product_unit > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_174, type, esk46_3: set_b > set_b > set_Product_prod_b_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_175, type, esk47_3: set_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Pr454823535od_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_176, type, esk48_2: (a > $o) > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_177, type, esk49_2: (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_178, type, esk50_2: (b > $o) > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_179, type, esk51_2: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_180, type, esk52_3: set_Product_prod_b_a > (a > $o) > b > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_181, type, esk53_3: refine432681134nres_b > b > set_Product_prod_b_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_182, type, esk54_3: refine432681134nres_b > product_unit > set_Pr712638521unit_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_183, type, esk55_3: refine424419629nres_a > product_unit > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_184, type, esk56_3: refine432681134nres_b > a > set_Product_prod_a_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_185, type, esk57_3: refine424419629nres_a > a > set_Product_prod_a_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_186, type, esk58_3: refine787176636t_unit > b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_187, type, esk59_3: refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_188, type, esk60_3: refine787176636t_unit > a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_189, type, esk61_3: refine424419629nres_a > b > set_Product_prod_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_190, type, esk62_3: refine891721109od_b_a > b > set_Pr1323534894od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_191, type, esk63_3: refine432681134nres_b > b > set_Product_prod_b_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_192, type, esk64_3: refine432681134nres_b > product_unit > set_Pr712638521unit_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_193, type, esk65_3: refine424419629nres_a > product_unit > set_Pr1720557880unit_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_194, type, esk66_3: refine432681134nres_b > a > set_Product_prod_a_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_195, type, esk67_3: refine424419629nres_a > a > set_Product_prod_a_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_196, type, esk68_3: refine787176636t_unit > b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_197, type, esk69_3: refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_198, type, esk70_3: refine787176636t_unit > a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_199, type, esk71_3: refine424419629nres_a > b > set_Product_prod_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_200, type, esk72_3: refine891721109od_b_a > b > set_Pr1323534894od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_201, type, esk73_1: refine424419629nres_a > set_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_202, type, esk74_1: refine787176636t_unit > set_Product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_203, type, esk75_1: refine432681134nres_b > set_b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_204, type, esk76_1: refine891721109od_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_205, type, esk77_1: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_206, type, esk78_1: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_207, type, esk79_1: product_prod_b_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_208, type, esk80_1: product_prod_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_209, type, esk81_1: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_210, type, esk82_1: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_211, type, esk83_1: product_prod_b_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_212, type, esk84_1: product_prod_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_213, type, esk85_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_214, type, esk86_2: set_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_215, type, esk87_2: set_Product_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_216, type, esk88_2: set_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_217, type, esk89_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_218, type, esk90_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_219, type, esk91_3: refine787176636t_unit > refine432681134nres_b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_220, type, esk92_3: refine787176636t_unit > refine424419629nres_a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_221, type, esk93_3: refine787176636t_unit > refine891721109od_b_a > set_Pr975006126t_unit > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_222, type, esk94_3: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_223, type, esk95_3: refine424419629nres_a > refine432681134nres_b > set_Product_prod_b_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_224, type, esk96_4: refine432681134nres_b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > b > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_225, type, esk97_3: refine432681134nres_b > set_Pr1707992533t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_226, type, esk98_4: refine424419629nres_a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > a > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_227, type, esk99_3: refine424419629nres_a > set_Pr1628433942t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_228, type, esk100_4: refine891721109od_b_a > set_Pr975006126t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_prod_b_a > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_229, type, esk101_3: refine891721109od_b_a > set_Pr975006126t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_230, type, esk102_4: refine787176636t_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_231, type, esk103_3: refine787176636t_unit > set_Pr451126599t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_232, type, esk104_4: refine432681134nres_b > set_Product_prod_b_a > refine424419629nres_a > b > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_233, type, esk105_3: refine432681134nres_b > set_Product_prod_b_a > refine424419629nres_a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_234, type, esk106_2: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_235, type, esk107_2: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_236, type, esk108_2: refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_237, type, esk109_2: refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_238, type, esk110_2: refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_239, type, esk111_2: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_240, type, esk112_2: refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_241, type, esk113_2: refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_242, type, esk114_2: refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_243, type, esk115_2: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_244, type, esk116_2: refine432681134nres_b > refine432681134nres_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_245, type, esk117_2: refine424419629nres_a > refine424419629nres_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_246, type, esk118_2: refine891721109od_b_a > refine891721109od_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_247, type, esk119_2: refine787176636t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_248, type, esk120_2: (a > $o) > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_249, type, esk121_2: (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_250, type, esk122_2: (b > $o) > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_251, type, esk123_2: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_252, type, esk124_2: (a > $o) > (a > $o) > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_253, type, esk125_2: (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_254, type, esk126_2: (b > $o) > (b > $o) > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_255, type, esk127_2: (product_prod_b_a > $o) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_256, type, esk128_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_257, type, esk129_2: set_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_258, type, esk130_2: set_Product_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_259, type, esk131_2: set_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_260, type, esk132_2: set_Product_prod_b_a > set_Product_prod_b_a > product_prod_b_a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_261, type, esk133_2: set_a > set_a > a). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_262, type, esk134_2: set_Product_unit > set_Product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_263, type, esk135_2: set_b > set_b > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_264, type, esk136_3: set_Product_prod_b_a > refine432681134nres_b > a > b). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_265, type, esk137_3: set_Pr451126599t_unit > refine787176636t_unit > product_unit > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_266, type, esk138_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_267, type, esk139_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_268, type, esk140_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_269, type, esk141_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_270, type, esk142_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_271, type, esk143_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_272, type, esk144_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_273, type, esk145_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > (product_unit > refine787176636t_unit) > (product_unit > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_274, type, esk146_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > (product_unit > refine432681134nres_b) > (b > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_275, type, esk147_5: refine787176636t_unit > (product_unit > refine424419629nres_a) > (a > $o) > (product_unit > refine891721109od_b_a) > (product_prod_b_a > $o) > product_unit). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_276, type, epred1_1: set_a > a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_277, type, epred2_1: set_Product_unit > product_unit > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_278, type, epred3_1: set_b > b > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(decl_279, type, epred4_1: set_Product_prod_b_a > product_prod_b_a > $o). 0.36/0.57 thf(fact_110_RETURN__RES__refine__iff, axiom, ![X291:b, X85:set_Product_prod_b_a, X292:set_a]:(((ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ X291) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ X85 @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X292)))<=>?[X288:a]:(((member_a @ X288 @ X292)&(member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ X291 @ X288) @ X85))))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', fact_110_RETURN__RES__refine__iff)). 0.36/0.57 thf(fact_12_assms, axiom, ?[X25:a]:(((member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ x2 @ X25) @ r)&(member_a @ X25 @ x))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', fact_12_assms)). 0.36/0.57 thf(conj_0, conjecture, (ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ x2) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ r @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ x))), file('/export/starexec/sandbox2/benchmark/theBenchmark.p', conj_0)). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_3, plain, ![X2344:b, X2345:set_Product_prod_b_a, X2346:set_a, X2348:b, X2349:set_Product_prod_b_a, X2350:set_a, X2351:a]:(((((member_a @ (esk30_3 @ X2344 @ X2345 @ X2346) @ X2346)|~(ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ X2344) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ X2345 @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X2346))))&((member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ X2344 @ (esk30_3 @ X2344 @ X2345 @ X2346)) @ X2345)|~(ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ X2344) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ X2345 @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X2346)))))&(~(member_a @ X2351 @ X2350)|~(member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ X2348 @ X2351) @ X2349)|(ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ X2348) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ X2349 @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X2350)))))), inference(distribute,[status(thm)],[inference(shift_quantors,[status(thm)],[inference(skolemize,[status(esa)],[inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[inference(shift_quantors,[status(thm)],[inference(fof_nnf,[status(thm)],[fact_110_RETURN__RES__refine__iff])])])])])])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_4, plain, ((member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ x2 @ esk1_0) @ r)&(member_a @ esk1_0 @ x)), inference(skolemize,[status(esa)],[inference(variable_rename,[status(thm)],[fact_12_assms])])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_5, plain, ![X21:b, X17:a, X7:set_a, X5:set_Product_prod_b_a]:(((ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ X21) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ X5 @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X7)))|~((member_a @ X17 @ X7))|~((member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ X21 @ X17) @ X5)))), inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c_0_3])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_6, plain, (member1277678991od_b_a @ (product_Pair_b_a @ x2 @ esk1_0) @ r), inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c_0_4])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_7, negated_conjecture, ~(ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ x2) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ r @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ x))), inference(fof_simplification,[status(thm)],[inference(assume_negation,[status(cth)],[conj_0])])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_8, plain, ![X7:set_a]:(((ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ x2) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ r @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ X7)))|~((member_a @ esk1_0 @ X7)))), inference(spm,[status(thm)],[c_0_5, c_0_6])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_9, plain, (member_a @ esk1_0 @ x), inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c_0_4])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_10, negated_conjecture, ~((ord_le527798542nres_b @ (refine2063221605TURN_b @ x2) @ (refine122110612un_b_a @ r @ (refine1198353288_RES_a @ x)))), inference(split_conjunct,[status(thm)],[c_0_7])). 0.36/0.57 thf(c_0_11, plain, ($false), inference(sr,[status(thm)],[inference(spm,[status(thm)],[c_0_8, c_0_9]), c_0_10]), ['proof']). 0.36/0.57 # SZS output end CNFRefutation 0.36/0.57 # Parsed axioms : 505 0.36/0.57 # Removed by relevancy pruning/SinE : 0 0.36/0.57 # Initial clauses : 903 0.36/0.57 # Removed in clause preprocessing : 204 0.36/0.57 # Initial clauses in saturation : 699 0.36/0.57 # Processed clauses : 777 0.36/0.57 # ...of these trivial : 50 0.36/0.57 # ...subsumed : 111 0.36/0.57 # ...remaining for further processing : 616 0.36/0.57 # Other redundant clauses eliminated : 33 0.36/0.57 # Clauses deleted for lack of memory : 0 0.36/0.57 # Backward-subsumed : 0 0.36/0.57 # Backward-rewritten : 2 0.36/0.57 # Generated clauses : 2458 0.36/0.57 # ...of the previous two non-redundant : 1956 0.36/0.57 # ...aggressively subsumed : 0 0.36/0.57 # Contextual simplify-reflections : 39 0.36/0.57 # Paramodulations : 2387 0.36/0.57 # Factorizations : 14 0.36/0.57 # NegExts : 0 0.36/0.57 # Equation resolutions : 43 0.36/0.57 # Propositional unsat checks : 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional check models : 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional check unsatisfiable : 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional clauses : 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional clauses after purity: 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional unsat core size : 0 0.36/0.57 # Propositional preprocessing time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Propositional encoding time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Propositional solver time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Success case prop preproc time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Success case prop encoding time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Success case prop solver time : 0.000 0.36/0.57 # Current number of processed clauses : 602 0.36/0.57 # Positive orientable unit clauses : 69 0.36/0.57 # Positive unorientable unit clauses: 0 0.36/0.57 # Negative unit clauses : 2 0.36/0.57 # Non-unit-clauses : 531 0.36/0.57 # Current number of unprocessed clauses: 1878 0.36/0.57 # ...number of literals in the above : 5314 0.36/0.57 # Current number of archived formulas : 0 0.36/0.57 # Current number of archived clauses : 2 0.36/0.57 # Clause-clause subsumption calls (NU) : 49263 0.36/0.57 # Rec. Clause-clause subsumption calls : 44393 0.36/0.57 # Non-unit clause-clause subsumptions : 153 0.36/0.57 # Unit Clause-clause subsumption calls : 3572 0.36/0.57 # Rewrite failures with RHS unbound : 0 0.36/0.57 # BW rewrite match attempts : 24 0.36/0.57 # BW rewrite match successes : 2 0.36/0.57 # Condensation attempts : 777 0.36/0.57 # Condensation successes : 6 0.36/0.57 # Termbank termtop insertions : 107102 0.36/0.57 0.36/0.57 # ------------------------------------------------- 0.36/0.57 # User time : 0.144 s 0.36/0.57 # System time : 0.015 s 0.36/0.57 # Total time : 0.159 s 0.36/0.57 # Maximum resident set size: 6060 pages 0.36/0.57 0.36/0.57 # ------------------------------------------------- 0.36/0.57 # User time : 0.159 s 0.36/0.57 # System time : 0.018 s 0.36/0.57 # Total time : 0.177 s 0.36/0.57 # Maximum resident set size: 2800 pages 0.36/0.57 EOF